写作与投稿科研写作与发表Lylll9436/Paper-Polish-Workflow-skill写作与投稿
PP

ppw:logic

维护者 Lylll9436 · 最近更新 2026年4月1日

Verify logical consistency across paper sections. Traces argument chains and identifies gaps, unsupported claims, terminology inconsistencies, and number contradictions. 论文逻辑验证,识别论证链断裂、无支撑声明、术语不一致、数字矛盾。

Claude Code写作整理投稿回应ppw-logicpaper-polishwritingsubmission

原始来源

Lylll9436/Paper-Polish-Workflow-skill

https://github.com/Lylll9436/Paper-Polish-Workflow-skill/tree/main/skills/ppw-logic

维护者
Lylll9436
许可
See upstream repo
最近更新
2026年4月1日

技能摘要

来自 SKILL.md 的关键信息

2 min

核心说明

  • This Skill reads full academic paper 、 verifies logical consistency across its sections. It identifies four types of issues — argument chain gaps (AC-),unsupported claims (UC-),terminology inconsistencies (TI-),、 number contradictions (NC-) — 、 produces two-part bilingual report. Part 1 maps each section's primary claim as Argument Chain View table,showing how claims connect (或 fail to connect) ,面向 Introduction through Conclusion. Part 2 categorizes every identified issue ,支持 problem description,impact statement,、 one-sentence directional suggestion,each followed by inline Chinese translation. Skill never rewrites text;it identifies 、 suggests only。
  • 你是一位负责论文终稿校对的学术助手。你的任务是进行"红线审查",确保论文没有致命错误。

原始文档

SKILL.md 摘录

Core Prompt

Source: awesome-ai-research-writing — 逻辑检查


## Constraints

1. 审查阈值(高容忍度):
   - 默认假设:请预设当前的草稿已经经过了多轮修改与校正,质量较高。
   - 仅报错原则:只有在遇到阻碍读者理解的逻辑断层、引起歧义的术语混乱、或严重的语法错误时才提出意见。
   - 严禁优化:对于"可改可不改"的风格问题、或者仅仅是"换个词听起来更高级"的建议,请直接忽略,不要通过挑刺来体现你的存在感。

2. 审查维度:
   - 致命逻辑:是否存在前后完全矛盾的陈述?
   - 术语一致性:核心概念是否在没有说明的情况下换了名字?
   - 严重语病:是否存在导致句意不清的中式英语(Chinglish)或语法结构错误。

3. 输出格式:
   - 如果没有上述"必须修改"的错误,请直接输出中文:[检测通过,无实质性问题]。
   - 如果有问题,请使用中文分点简要指出,不要长篇大论。

Modes

ModeDefaultBehavior
directYesSingle-pass full-paper analysis, no intermediate confirmation steps
batchNot supported — cross-section logic verification requires full-paper context

Default mode: direct. User provides the paper and receives a complete two-part logic report.

适用场景

  • Use ppw:logic ,用于 manuscript drafting 、 submission workflows。
  • Apply ppw:logic when polishing research communication outputs。

不适用场景

  • Do not treat this catalog entry as substitute ,用于 full upstream workflow。

相关技能

相关技能

返回目录
BI
写作与投稿科研写作与发表

bio-alignment-io

bio-alignment-io:Read,write,、 convert multiple sequence alignment files ,使用 Biopython Bio.AlignIO。 支持 Clustal,PHYLIP,Sto…

OpenClawNanoClaw写作整理
FreedomIntelligence/OpenClaw-Medical-Skills查看
DO
写作与投稿科研写作与发表

doc-coauthoring

doc-coauthoring:指引 users through structured workflow ,用于 co-authoring documentation。 This workflow helps users efficient…

OpenClawNanoClaw写作整理
FreedomIntelligence/OpenClaw-Medical-Skills查看
PA
写作与投稿科研写作与发表

paper-polish-workflow

paper-polish-workflow:Systematic top-down workflow ,用于 polishing academic papers。 Structure to logic to expression ,支持 u…

Claude Code写作整理
Lylll9436/Paper-Polish-Workflow-skill查看
PP
写作与投稿科研写作与发表

ppw:abstract

Generate or optimize academic paper abstracts using the 5-sentence Farquhar formula. Supports generate-from-scratch and…

Claude Code写作整理
Lylll9436/Paper-Polish-Workflow-skill查看